Skip to content

Veterinary Health and Safety: Consultant or DIY

By Brian Crocker · Published

The law has an opinion about this, and it is not the one you would expect

Most practices reach the consultant question the same way. An assessment date appears, or an incident happens, or a new manager opens the H&S folder and finds documents dated 2021. Someone searches for a veterinary health and safety consultant, gets three quotes that are harder to compare than expected, and has to decide.

Before comparing quotes, it is worth knowing that the underlying regulation already has a stated preference.

Regulation 7 of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 requires that "every employer shall... appoint one or more competent persons to assist him in undertaking the measures he needs to take to comply with the requirements and prohibitions imposed upon him by or under the relevant statutory provisions."

Then it says this: "Where there is a competent person in the employer's employment, that person shall be appointed for the purposes of paragraph (1) in preference to a competent person not in his employment."

That is the law expressing a preference for in-house competence over bought-in competence. Not a prohibition on consultants — plenty of practices need one — but a default that points the other way from the one most practices assume.

One territorial note before going further, because it applies to everything below. Regulation 7 carries an E+W+S extent marker, and the 1999 Regulations are made under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974, which provides at section 84(1) that "This Act, except— ... does not extend to Northern Ireland." A practice in Northern Ireland finds the same preference in regulation 7 of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2000, made under the Health and Safety at Work (Northern Ireland) Order 1978. The substance of this guide holds either way; only the citations change.

What "competent" actually means

The same regulation defines it, and the definition is less intimidating than the word:

"A person shall be regarded as competent for the purposes of paragraphs (1) and (8) where he has sufficient training and experience or knowledge and other qualities to enable him properly to assist in undertaking the measures referred to in paragraph (1)."

Sufficient training and experience or knowledge and other qualities. No named qualification. No certificate specified. The test is whether the person can properly do the job in front of them.

For a five-vet practice, the job in front of them is a defined and finite list: animal handling, zoonoses, sharps, manual handling, slips and trips, radiation where there is imaging, anaesthetic gases, chemicals, lone working, and the paperwork that evidences all of it. A practice manager or head nurse who has worked through that list, understands why each control exists, and keeps the records current is very plausibly competent within the meaning of regulation 7. Someone who has been handed a folder and told to own it is not — and no external consultant fixes that, because regulation 7 does not let you delegate the duty away.

What you cannot buy in

Two things stay with the practice however much you spend.

The duty itself. The employer holds it. A consultant assists; they do not assume it. If a control fails, the question is what the practice did, not what its adviser advised.

The written policy. Section 2(3) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 requires every employer "to prepare and as often as may be appropriate revise a written statement of his general policy with respect to the health and safety at work of his employees and the organisation and arrangements for the time being in force for carrying out that policy, and to bring the statement and any revision of it to the notice of all of his employees."

Note the last clause. Preparing the statement is half of it; bringing it to the notice of all employees is the other half, and it is the half a consultant cannot do for you.

Section 2 is part of the 1974 Act, so the territorial point above applies here too: in Northern Ireland the same written-policy duty sits in article 4(3) of the Health and Safety at Work (Northern Ireland) Order 1978, which requires an employer to "prepare and as often as may be appropriate revise a written statement of his general policy with respect to the health and safety at work of his employees".

The commonly-cited five-employee threshold is real but it does not sit in section 2(3) itself — the section says "except in such cases as may be prescribed", and the exception comes from the Employers' Health and Safety Policy Statements (Exception) Regulations 1975, which except "any employer who carries on an undertaking in which for the time being he employs less than five employees". Almost every veterinary practice is over that line. The duty in section 2 to ensure health and safety so far as is reasonably practicable applies regardless of headcount; only the written statement is excepted.

Where a consultant genuinely earns the fee

Being honest about this matters more than being contrarian about it. Buy help when:

  • Nobody in the practice has the knowledge yet, and the gap is wide. If the folder is four years stale and nobody knows which parts are wrong, an external pass gets you to a known baseline faster than a self-taught year.
  • You need a specialist assessment. Radiation protection adviser duties under IRR17 are a defined role — see our guide to veterinary X-ray radiation protection. Certain COSHH exposure measurements need equipment and expertise a practice will not hold.
  • You are multi-site. Consistency across sites is harder than compliance at one, and an external eye finds the drift.
  • Something has gone wrong. After a serious incident or an enforcement contact, independent advice is worth having, and worth having quickly.
  • The alternative is nothing. A consultant who keeps a practice compliant beats an in-house intention that never gets time. This is the most common honest answer and the least often said out loud.

Where it does not

  • When you buy documents rather than competence. A thick folder of risk assessments written off a template, filed and never revisited, is worse than a shorter set the practice wrote itself — because nobody in the building knows what is in it or why.
  • When the annual visit becomes the compliance cycle. Assessments are due when circumstances change, not when the consultant is next booked. A practice that changes waste contractor in March and reviews it in November has an eight-month gap the visit did not cause but did conceal.
  • When it is generic. A consultant with no veterinary experience will bring good process and the wrong hazards. Ask what they know about zoonoses, scavenging and animal handling before you ask about price.
  • When it replaces the review rather than supporting it. The HSE inspection questions are about what the practice does, not what its adviser wrote.

The middle option most practices end up in

Neither pure DIY nor a full retainer, but a deliberate split:

  • In-house: the day-to-day. Reviewing assessments when things change, keeping training records current, running the incident process including the RIDDOR decision, maintaining SOPs, holding the waste and COSHH files.
  • Bought in: the specialist and the periodic. RPA duties, an initial baseline where one is needed, a periodic independent check, and access to advice when something unusual arrives.
  • Invested in: the named person's competence. A recognised general certificate, veterinary-specific H&S training, or structured time to work through the risk assessment set properly. This is what turns regulation 7's preference from a technicality into an accurate description of your practice.

That split usually costs less than a retainer, and it produces something a retainer does not: someone in the building who knows why each control exists.

Four questions before you sign anything

  1. Who is our competent person, and are they in our employment? If the honest answer is "the consultant", regulation 7's preference is being applied backwards and it is worth asking why.
  2. What do we get that we could not do ourselves within six months? If the answer is documents, buy the documents once. If it is knowledge, buy the training instead.
  3. What happens between visits? Compliance runs continuously. Any model where the file is only current on visit day has a gap by design.
  4. Would an inspector conclude the practice understands its own risks, or that it outsourced them? That is the question actually being answered on the day.

Everything above turns on the same thing: whether the evidence stays current between the moments anyone looks at it. A consultant can build the file. Only the practice can keep it.


VetComply is being built to keep H&S, COSHH, training, waste and the rest of the non-clinical streams current in one place, with review dates tracked rather than remembered — so the in-house option is a realistic one. Join the waitlist for early access.


This is general guidance based on the published Act and Regulations as they stood at the review date above. The HSE is the authority on how these duties apply to your practice — check with them, or with a suitably experienced adviser, where the right arrangement for your practice is unclear.

Sources:

Manage all your practice compliance in one place

VetComply brings CMA compliance, RCVS PSS preparation, H&S, COSHH, and 8 more compliance streams into a single dashboard. Join the waitlist for early access.

We'll email you once when VetComply launches. Ask to be removed any time. Privacy policy.